One Who Wishes to Be Pious — On Blessings, Intention, and Reliance

by Ram ben Ze'ev

One Who Wishes to Be Pious — On Blessings, Intention, and Reliance

Within Judaism, there exists a necessary tension between precision and presence. On the one hand, we are commanded not to take the Name of the L-RD in vain, which our Sages understood as refraining from unnecessary, careless, or hollow utterance. On the other hand, we are taught to recognise G-D in all things: as the Provider of sustenance, the Source of existence, and the sustaining force of creation itself. According to the Holy Zohar, there is nothing that exists outside G-D; all that is, exists within His will and vitality.

Halakhah, therefore, does not exist to reduce our awareness of G-D, but to discipline it. It structures how we express praise, not whether praise is fitting. It teaches us when, how, and in what manner we acknowledge G-D, so that our words are aligned with intention and responsibility.

Our Sages set detailed laws governing blessings: which blessing is recited, when it is recited, how much must be eaten to require it, and what is done in cases of doubt, omission, or error. These laws are not obstacles to devotion; they are vessels for it. Nevertheless, Halakhah also recognises that a person is not judged by whom they relied upon, but by whom they chose to rely upon. When one stands in judgment, one cannot say, “I relied upon this Rabbi or that authority.” One can only answer for one’s own service, undertaken לשם שמים (Leshem Shamayim — for the sake of Heaven).

It was in this spirit that our Sages taught: “One who wishes to be pious should be meticulous regarding the laws of blessings.” This statement is not merely technical; it is directional. It assumes that blessing G-D is good, desirable, and essential, and that the question before us is not whether to praise G-D, but how carefully and consciously we do so.

In matters where there is a disagreement among the Poskim concerning blessings, Halakhah may follow one view. Yet, where possible, it is praiseworthy to act in a manner that avoids doubt altogether. This is not out of fear of error alone, but out of reverence for the act of blessing itself. Avoiding a situation in which one might be required to bless but is unable to do so is not a restriction of praise; it is a protection of it.

For this reason, in cases such as eating a single grape or similar complete item that does not reach the volume of an olive, it is appropriate to either eat less than a whole unit or to eat an olive’s volume or more, thereby fulfilling all opinions and allowing the after-blessing to be recited without uncertainty. This approach reflects not caution born of anxiety, but devotion born of clarity.

Similarly, when tasting food not for pleasure but for preparation, Halakhah recognises that no blessing is required. Yet one who wishes to be pious may intend enjoyment and thereby create an opportunity to bless according to all views. This is not excess; it is conscious service.

Therefore, this ruling affirms the following principle:

It is not possible to praise G-D too much when praise is offered with intention, humility, and responsibility. Halakhah does not seek to limit acknowledgment of G-D’s presence in the world; it seeks to ensure that such acknowledgment is truthful, meaningful, and worthy of the Name being spoken.

One must study, one must decide, and one must act. Each blessing is an act of reliance. The only enduring question is this: Upon whom will you rely?

May our blessings be many, our intentions be clear, and our service be for the sake of Heaven alone.

###

About Hebrew Synagogue

Hebrew Synagogue is an independent advisory body on matters pertaining to Jewish religious practice, interpretation, and applied Halakhah. It is widely consulted by individuals, institutions, and agencies seeking clear, faithful, and principled guidance rooted in Torah, the Talmud, the writings of the Rishonim and Acharonim, and the inner teachings of Judaism, including the Holy Zohar and Chassidic thought.

Hebrew Synagogue provides Halakhic rulings, clarifications, and supplemental guidance intended to illuminate existing practice rather than replace it. Its work is characterised by careful analysis, intellectual honesty, and an unwavering commitment to service לשם שמים (Leshem Shamayim — for the sake of Heaven). Where questions arise from modern life, new technologies, or contemporary social conditions, Hebrew Synagogue addresses them through the lens of traditional Jewish sources, applying eternal principles to present realities.

In addition to Halakhic guidance, Hebrew Synagogue is engaged in the preparation, publication, and dissemination of Jewish liturgical and study works. This includes structured prayer books, study texts, translations, and explanatory writings designed to preserve fidelity to original sources while making them accessible to the serious English reader. Particular care is taken with language, structure, and meaning, ensuring that Jewish concepts are not distorted through foreign theological frameworks.

Hebrew Synagogue also serves an educational role, offering teachings, essays, and public guidance on core Jewish ideas such as אמונה (emunah — faith), בטחון (bitachon — trust in G-D), תשובה (teshuvah — return), speech ethics, daily religious conduct, and the sanctification of ordinary life through mindful practice. Its teachings emphasise personal responsibility, informed choice, and the understanding that each individual ultimately stands accountable for their own service of G-D.

Hebrew Synagogue does not function as a congregation or a political body. It exists to advise, to clarify, and to uphold the integrity of Jewish religious life through learning, precision, and reverence. Its approach assumes that praising G-D is inherently good, and that the role of Halakhah is to guide that praise so it is meaningful, truthful, and worthy.

Executive Director: Ram ben Ze'ev