When Scotland Remembered — And Will Remember Again
- WireNews
- 16 hours ago
- 2 min read
by Ram ben Ze'ev
There are moments in a nation’s life when it must dare to ask an uncomfortable question: What if we have forgotten part of ourselves?
The book When Scotland Was Jewish by Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman and Donald N. Yates is not a casual historical curiosity. It is a challenge. Drawing upon DNA evidence, archaeology, migration analysis, and public and family records, the authors argue that from the twelfth century onward, Scotland carried within her bloodstream a significant Semitic inheritance.
This is not the romantic fantasy of “lost tribes.” It is a thesis rooted in genealogies, trade records, surnames, coins, church architecture, academic networks, and commercial patterns that connected Scotland not merely to England or Scandinavia — but to France, Spain, the Low Countries, and the Mediterranean world.
For those of us who care about Scotland and about Jewish continuity, the implications are profound.
If even part of this thesis is correct, then Scotland was not simply a Celtic outpost on the Atlantic fringe. It was a crossroads. A refuge. A participant in the great mercantile and intellectual networks that Jewish communities helped to build across Europe.
And if that is so, then the story of Scotland and the story of the Jewish people are not parallel narratives — they are interwoven ones.
Today, Scotland’s Jewish community is small. In numbers, it is fragile. Yet history reminds us that Jewish presence in lands far from Zion has often preceded flourishing contribution.
Wherever Jews settled — through commerce, scholarship, law, medicine, and ethical monotheism — they helped elevate civic culture, literacy, and economic vitality.
Scotland needs that vitality again.
A regrowth of Jewish life in Scotland would not be an imposition from outside. It would be, in many ways, a return. A restoration. A re-anchoring of moral clarity in a society that is searching for identity amidst cultural uncertainty.
Jewish community is not merely demographic. It is covenantal. It is the presence of בתי כנסת (batei knesset – houses of assembly), of בתי מדרש (batei midrash – houses of study), of families who live by תורה (Torah) and who understand that a nation’s strength flows from moral discipline, not from sentiment.
Scotland, with its fierce independence and intellectual seriousness, is fertile soil for renewal.
The book When Scotland Was Jewish should therefore not be read merely as revisionist history. It should be read as invitation. An invitation to examine surnames, records, migrations, and forgotten links. An invitation for those of possible Jewish ancestry to explore their roots with honesty. An invitation for Jews worldwide — especially in Britain and Europe — to see Scotland not as peripheral, but as meaningful ground.
The future of Jewish Scotland will not be built on romanticism. It will be built on commitment: to learning, to community, to observance, to integrity.
History may have concealed chapters of Scotland’s Jewish past. But concealment is not erasure.
Nations, like people, can rediscover who they are.
And perhaps Scotland’s rediscovery is yet to come.
###
Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews Limited, Mayside Partners Limited, MEADHANAN Agency, Kestrel Assets Limited, SpudsToGo Limited and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue
