top of page

The Folly of Starship

Updated: Nov 20

by Ram ben Ze'ev (Conservative Values)

SpaceX launched its second test rocket but the mission ended in two explosions
SpaceX launched its second test rocket but the mission ended in two explosions

SpaceX experienced another unsuccessful Starship test flight today, as both the booster rocket and the spacecraft exploded within a few minutes of liftoff.

Under the leadership of Elon Musk, SpaceX has undeniably revolutionised space travel with its ambitious projects. Among these, the Starship programme stands out as the crown jewel, promising interplanetary exploration and the colonisation of Mars. However, beneath the glittering façade, the SpaceX Starship project harbours several critical shortcomings that deserve closer scrutiny.

One of the primary concerns surrounding the SpaceX Starship programme is the overly optimistic timelines set by Elon Musk. While ambitious goals can drive innovation, they must be tempered with a sense of realism. SpaceX's consistently missed deadlines for the Starship's development raise questions about the feasibility of the project. Unforeseen technical challenges, funding issues, and regulatory hurdles have repeatedly pushed back the timeline, casting doubt on the project's viability. Then, there's the exploding rockets.

The Starship's proposed design, with its stainless-steel construction and fully reusable architecture, presents numerous technological challenges. Achieving successful reusability on such a large scale has never been attempted before, and SpaceX faces an uphill battle in making this concept a reality. The complexities of refurbishing a spacecraft of this magnitude after each use may undermine the economic advantages of reusability.

SpaceX's commitment to sustainability has been a cornerstone of its public image. However, the environmental impact of the Starship programme has not been adequately addressed. The colossal scale of the Starship, coupled with its extensive use of fossil fuels during launch, raises concerns about the project's contribution to carbon emissions. In an era where environmental responsibility is paramount, the lack of a comprehensive plan to mitigate these impacts is a significant oversight.

While Elon Musk envisions a future where the Starship facilitates the colonisation of Mars, the economic viability of such a venture remains questionable. The colossal cost of developing and launching the Starship, coupled with the uncertainties surrounding its reusability, calls into question the feasibility of establishing a self-sustaining human presence on Mars. The economic model for a Mars colony remains speculative and may not withstand the financial pressures and uncertainties inherent in space exploration.

SpaceX's Starship project faces an array of regulatory challenges that could impede its progress. The complexities of international space law, safety regulations, and ethical considerations surrounding Mars colonisation are formidable. Navigating this intricate web of regulations requires a level of diplomacy and cooperation that is yet to be demonstrated by SpaceX. Ignoring or underestimating these regulatory hurdles could have profound consequences for the project's success.

The space industry is becoming increasingly crowded, with several formidable players vying for dominance. SpaceX's Starship faces stiff competition from other space agencies and private companies, each with their own ambitious projects. As the landscape evolves, SpaceX must contend not only with technical challenges but also with the shifting dynamics of the space industry. The assumption that SpaceX will maintain a leading position in the space race may be overly optimistic.

While the SpaceX Starship project has captured the imagination of space enthusiasts worldwide, a critical examination reveals a series of substantial challenges that could undermine its success. From overambitious timelines and technological hurdles to environmental concerns and regulatory challenges, the folly of the Starship project is multifaceted. And then, there's the exploding rockets.

Acknowledging these limitations does not diminish the remarkable achievements of SpaceX in advancing space exploration. However, a realistic assessment is necessary to foster a more informed and balanced perspective on the challenges ahead. Only by addressing these concerns openly and proactively can SpaceX hope to navigate the complex journey to make the Starship a truly revolutionary spacecraft.


Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue

bottom of page