by Ram ben Ze'ev
The British government has announced new legislation that will require millers and flour producers to fortify non-wholemeal wheat flour with folic acid starting at the end of 2026. This measure, aimed at reducing neural tube defects in newborns, seeks to improve public health outcomes by increasing folic acid intake among the population. However, this mandatory fortification policy presents several potential risks that should not be overlooked. Compulsory folic acid supplementation may lead to unintended health consequences, affecting various segments of the population and raising questions about whether universal fortification is the best approach.
Risk of Masking Vitamin B12 Deficiency
One significant concern is that increased folic acid intake can mask the symptoms of vitamin B12 deficiency. Vitamin B12 is crucial for neurological function and red blood cell production, and a deficiency can lead to severe neurological damage if left untreated. Excessive folic acid can mask the blood-related symptoms of B12 deficiency, potentially delaying diagnosis and treatment. This issue is especially relevant to older adults, who are at a higher risk for vitamin B12 deficiency. Without clear symptoms, individuals may not seek timely medical attention, increasing the risk of irreversible neurological damage.
Potential Increase in Cancer Risk
Some studies have raised concerns that high levels of folic acid might increase the risk of certain cancers, especially in individuals with pre-cancerous conditions. Unlike natural folate, which is found in foods such as leafy greens, synthetic folic acid might stimulate the growth of pre-existing cancerous cells. While folic acid can offer benefits for pregnant women, the potential for increased cancer risk poses a significant consideration in a universal fortification policy, where consumers lack the ability to choose their folate sources and dosages.
Impact on the Immune System
High levels of folic acid have been linked to potential immune impairment. Synthetic folic acid can build up in the bloodstream when consumed in excessive amounts, possibly affecting immune function over time. This concern underscores the potential risk of blanket fortification, particularly among individuals who already obtain sufficient folic acid through their diet or supplements.
Risk of Overconsumption in a Modern Diet
Mandatory fortification could lead to excessive folic acid intake among those who already consume enriched foods or supplements. Many foods, such as cereals and certain processed items, are already fortified with folic acid, and many people take multivitamins containing folic acid. For these individuals, adding folic acid to non-wholemeal flour could result in an intake that exceeds recommended levels, increasing the likelihood of experiencing negative health effects.
Potential Allergic Reactions and Sensitivities
Though uncommon, some people may experience allergies or sensitivities to synthetic folic acid. Symptoms can include skin rashes, digestive issues, and other mild to moderate reactions. Allowing individuals to control their folic acid intake through dietary choices or supplements would help prevent such adverse reactions and respect individual health needs.
Alternative Approaches to Preventing Birth Defects
Preventing neural tube defects is a critical public health objective, but mandatory fortification may not be the best path forward given these potential risks. A more targeted approach, such as promoting awareness of folate-rich foods and encouraging prenatal supplementation, could help those who are most at risk without imposing unnecessary risks on the broader population.
While the upcoming legislation aims to address a pressing health concern, it is essential to carefully consider the potential health consequences. Weighing the benefits of mandatory fortification against its risks—masking vitamin B12 deficiency, potentially increasing cancer risk, impairing immune function, causing overconsumption, and triggering sensitivities—is vital as this policy moves forward. Public health goals are best served by policies that balance benefits with safety for all segments of the population.
###
Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews Limited, Mayside Partners Limited, MEADHANAN Agency, Kestrel Assets Limited (developer of MAYCOINS), SpudsToGo Limited and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue